By: Abby Miller  

Mar. 18, 2026 

With the 2025-2026 wrestling season in the books, the trophy case at Beeghly Gymnasium has grown more crowded. Following a dominant performance in the regular season and a hard-fought performance at the Presidents’ Athletics Conference (PAC) Championships, the Tomcats have once again proved themselves a regional powerhouse, led by a man who has become one with Pennsylvania wrestling excellence. This season, the Tomcats went 4-2 overall and 4-1 in the PAC. The team had a 26-man roster consisting of 12 freshmen, six sophomores, a quartet of juniors, a trio of seniors, and one graduate student.  

The Tomcats’ journey to the post-season was paved by several statement wins. In their home opener on January 22, Thiel dominated Bethany College with a 45-3 victory, followed by another resounding victory (46-9) over Waynesburg on Senior Night. To begin the post-season, the Tomcats traveled to Hiram, Ohio, for the PAC Championships on Feb. 14 with a clear goal: get on the podium. The Tomcats delivered, ending the day securing a second place team finish with 100 total points. The afternoon was highlighted by two conference titles. Junior Joey King capped off his notable season by defending his heavyweight position, while freshman Jonathan Bissell proved the bright lights of the post-season were not too bright for a newcomer, securing his conference title with a pin only 1:21 into the championship match. The momentum carried into the NCAA Regional IV Championships in Ada, Ohio, where the Tomcats placed 12th out of 20 teams. Mequan Maxwell, Jacob Potts, and Joey King posted top 8 finishes, earning All-Region honors.  

Yet another defining moment of the post-season ceremony was not another pin or a takedown, but a round of applause of Head Coach Craig Thurber. For the 10th time in his 23-year career at Thiel, Thurber was named PAC Coach of the Year. This award is a testament to more than just an overall record, but Thurber’s ability to build and shape a dedicated and winning team. Facing a big roster transition this season, Thurber was tasked with integrating 12 true freshmen into a lineup of seasoned veterans. A key component to this season’s success was his ability to transform the freshman and develop their skills. While the roster features many athletes from across the region, the emergence of local standouts like Jonathan Bissell has been a catalyst for the team’s energy.  

A local freshman out of Sharpsville, Bissell transitioned seamlessly from the high school mats of Mercer County to the collegiate level. Thurber’s ability to integrate Sharpsville talent like Bissell alongside Tomcat veterans like McCarthy and Potts, resulted in a lineup that was both balanced and competitive. Leading the roster with 19 pins, Bissell’s breakout season underscores the precision and grit behind the program’s recent success that defines Tomcat wrestling.  

With the graduation of seniors like Hunter Crouse, EJ McCarthy, and Landon Mead, the remaining Tomcats will have big shoes to fill, but the program is far from hitting a rebuilding stage. Between a legendary coach at the helm and a core of freshmen that has already proven they can hang in the PAC, the Thiel Tomcats are well-positioned to keep their legacy wrestling status for years to come.  

Leave a Reply